Skip to content
Thompson FourFoundationThe Thompson Four Foundation

Pillar Two

Thompson & Bethie

The service in this family did not begin with the Four. It began with their father, in the First World War — and with the mother who raised all four of them and then watched all four of them go.

The framed family display sheet titled World War I. At left, a portrait of Bethie Beatrice Farr Hanes in a dark hat. At center, a studio portrait of Bethie and Thompson with their infant son, Aubrey Lee, on a chair between them, Thompson in service coat, campaign hat, breeches and leggings. At right, a portrait of William Thompson Hanes in campaign hat.
The First World War panel of the family display sheet, restored for the web. Tone has been corrected; nothing has been added, removed or retouched.
Portrait of William Thompson Hanes in First World War uniform and campaign hat.

The father

William Thompson Hanes

1889 or 1891 – 1984

Thompson is the reason there is a Foundation rather than a scrapbook. The service in this family did not begin with the Four. It began with him.

He was a Hanes by birth, though the early records spell it Haynes. His mother was Sophronia Hanes. His father appears only as J. C. Hanes, born in Texas. In 1898 a Galveston city directory lists Sophronia, as Mrs. J. C. Hanes, working in a cotton mill, and Alvin and Barney Hanes, who lived with her, working there too. By June 1900 she had married again, to James Milstead, and the family lived in Grant Parish, Louisiana. The census taker found Thompson there at nine, listed as a stepson, with his older sister Vinie, his older brother Alvin, a younger brother, and a stepbrother, James.

The marriage failed. By November 1914 Sophronia had left Milstead and gone to live at Jena. On Sunday, November 29, 1914, she came back to Dry Prong on the afternoon train, to the home of her daughter, where a grandchild lay dead. Milstead came to the house and demanded that she go home with him. She refused. He shot her twice, and then he killed himself. She was taken to the sanitarium at Alexandria the next morning, and she died late in the afternoon of Tuesday, December 1. Her son, W. T. Hanes, took her body home to Jena for burial. He was in his twenties. Her stone reads: “Our Mother is gone but not forgotten.”

In the summer of 1918 he was a cook in Company B of the 347th Infantry, 87th Division. On August 26, 1918, his company sailed from New York for the war in Europe aboard the transport Persic. The Army’s passenger list gives the person to notify if anything happened to him: Mrs. Bethie Hanes, his wife, at Whitehouse, Texas. Aubrey Lee was just over a year old.

Twelve days later, on September 7, 1918, the Persic was torpedoed by the German submarine UB-87 near the Isles of Scilly, off the southwest tip of England. She was carrying about 2,800 American soldiers. She stayed afloat, the soldiers were taken off by destroyers, and nobody was lost. The New York Times reported it on September 12 under the headline “2,800 Escape U-Boat Attack.” The Foundation has not yet found a record that names Thompson among the men aboard at the time. But his company boarded the Persic in New York on August 26, and no transport could cross the Atlantic and come back for new troops in twelve days.

The Foundation now holds photographs of his own discharge papers, which the family keeps. They give the shape of his war in his own file. He was inducted at Colfax, Louisiana, on September 18, 1917, at twenty-five and a half, a farmer with no prior service. He went overseas with the American Expeditionary Forces on August 24, 1918, and the record gives his arrival at a port overseas as September 8 — the day after a German submarine torpedoed the Persic off the Isles of Scilly and destroyers took the troops off her. He left for home on December 24, 1918, reached the United States on December 30, and was discharged at Camp Pike, Arkansas, on January 16, 1919, by reason of demobilization. His character is recorded as “Very Good,” with no absence from duty, and the Army owed him travel pay to Colfax. He signed the sheet himself.

The discharge also settles a question this page has carried from the start. Where he was born, it reads: Natchez, in the State of Mississippi.

He is photographed in the uniform of the First World War: campaign hat, service coat, breeches and leggings. In the center photograph of the family display sheet he stands beside Bethie with an infant on a chair between them. The family identifies the child as Aubrey Lee. He looks about a year old, which is how old Aubrey Lee was when his father sailed, so the photograph and the Army’s passenger list agree.

He came home, and he and Bethie raised four children in Louisiana, and all four of them served. Whatever he taught them, he taught it well enough that it took four times.

He outlived Bethie by eleven years and died on April 24, 1984, in his nineties, at St. Francis Cabrini Hospital in Alexandria. His obituary called him a disabled Army veteran of the First World War. He was a member of the Veterans of Foreign Wars and of the Central Missionary Baptist Church near Tioga, and he is buried at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Pineville. Two years or so before the end, a local paper photographed him in a nursing home rhythm band, playing a harmonica ballad to raise money for the heart association. The Foundation keeps that clipping with the same care it keeps the uniforms. A man is not only his war.

The record as it stands

Born
March 2, 1889 or 1891Partial

His 1942 draft registration, which he signed, gives March 2, 1889. His grave marker gives March 2, 1891, and the 1900 census, the earliest record, gives March 1891. The day and month agree; the year does not.

Birthplace
Natchez, MississippiDocumented

His 1919 discharge and his 1942 draft registration, which he signed, and confirmed by the family. Three other sources give Louisiana; see the record note.

Mother
Sophronia Hanes Milstead, 1868 – 1914Documented

Her headstone, which spells her name Sefronia and gives June 26, 1868 – December 1, 1914. The 1900 census lists Thompson in her household, and a 1914 newspaper names W. T. Haynes as her son.

Father
J. C. Hanes, born in TexasPartial

A Galveston city directory of 1898 lists Sophronia as Mrs. J. C. Hanes. The 1900 census gives the father of her Hanes children as born in Texas. No record of him in his own name has been found.

Home, 1900
Ward 4, Grant Parish, LouisianaDocumented

1900 U.S. census, Grant Parish, Ward 4, enumerated June 27, 1900. He was nine, listed as a stepson, with his mother, his stepfather, a stepbrother, a sister and two brothers.

Inducted
September 18, 1917, at Colfax, LouisianaDocumented

His enlistment record, which also records no prior service

Overseas
Sailed August 24, 1918; arrived overseas September 8, 1918Documented

His enlistment record: “A.E.F. from U.S. for foreign service August 24, 1918. Arrived at port overseas Sept 8, 1918.” The transport list gives the sailing from New York as August 26.

Home
Left overseas December 24, 1918; reached the United States December 30, 1918Documented

His enlistment record

Unit at discharge
63rd Company, 16th Recruit Battalion, 162nd Depot BrigadeDocumented

His discharge, issued at Camp Pike, Arkansas

Discharged
January 16, 1919, at Camp Pike, Arkansas; honorableDocumented

His discharge, by reason of convenience of the government, demobilization. A stamp records $60 paid under the act of February 24, 1919.

Character
Very GoodDocumented

His enlistment record, which records no absence from duty and travel pay due to Colfax, Louisiana

Description, 1919
5 ft 8¼ in, blue eyes, light brown hair, ruddy complexionDocumented

His discharge. It gives his occupation at induction as farmer, and his age as 25½.

Discharge papers
Held by the familyDocumented

His honorable discharge, Form 525 A.G.O., and his enlistment record. Read from photographs of the originals, October 2026.

Veterans Administration claim
A claim file existsDocumented

A Veterans Administration claim number is written on his discharge. His 1984 obituary calls him a disabled veteran. The file has not yet been requested; claim files were kept apart from the service files lost in the 1973 fire.

Service
United States Army, First World WarDocumented

Army Transport Service passenger list, August 1918. The 1930 census also records him as a veteran of the World War, and his obituary calls him a disabled Army veteran of the First World War and a member of the Veterans of Foreign Wars.

Unit
Company B, 347th Infantry, 87th DivisionDocumented

Army Transport Service passenger list, Port of Embarkation, Hoboken, New Jersey

Grade
CookDocumented

Army Transport Service passenger list

Army serial number
2,104,693Documented

Army Transport Service passenger list

Sailed
August 26, 1918, from New York, aboard the transport PersicDocumented

Army Transport Service passenger list

Torpedoed
September 7, 1918, near the Isles of Scilly, aboard the PersicPartial

The Persic, carrying about 2,800 American troops, was damaged by a torpedo from the German submarine UB-87 on September 7, 1918, and all aboard survived. His company’s passenger list puts him on the Persic when it sailed from New York twelve days earlier, and his own enlistment record gives his arrival at a port overseas as September 8, the day after the attack. No record yet names him among those aboard at the moment the torpedo struck.

Service file
Official Military Personnel FilePending

SF-180 not yet filed. His serial number is now known, which makes the request stronger. Many Army records of his period were destroyed in the 1973 fire at the National Personnel Records Center.

Married
Bethie Beatrice FarrDocumented

Family display sheet. The 1918 transport list names Mrs. Bethie Hanes, of Whitehouse, Texas, as his wife and next of kin.

Home, 1930
Tioga, Rapides Parish, LouisianaDocumented

1930 U.S. census, Tioga Village, Ward 10, Rapides Parish, enumerated April 5, 1930

Registered to vote
February 9, 1953, Ward 10, Precinct 3, Rapides ParishDocumented

Louisiana voter registration certificate No. 51, for 1953–1956, signed W. T. Hanes. Bethie’s certificate, No. 50, was issued the same day.

Work, 1942
Farming, self-employed, at Rigolette, Rapides ParishDocumented

1942 draft registration card, which spells the place Rigollette

Description, 1942
5 ft 6 in, 179 lb, gray eyes, brown hair, ruddy complexionDocumented

1942 draft registration card, registrar’s report

Died
April 24, 1984, Alexandria, LouisianaDocumented

Grave marker, and his obituary in The Times, Shreveport, April 25, 1984

Bronze grave marker reading W. Thompson Hanes, March 2 1891 to April 24 1984, In Loving Memory.
W. Thompson Hanes, March 2, 1891 – April 24, 1984, as the marker reads. His own 1942 draft registration gives his birth year as 1889.
A worn, folded 1919 certificate headed Honorable Discharge from the United States Army, filled in by hand for Thompson Hanes, serial number 2104693, Cook, 63rd Company, 16th Recruit Battalion, 162nd Depot Brigade, born in Natchez, Mississippi, discharged at Camp Pike, Arkansas, on January 16, 1919.
His honorable discharge, signed at Camp Pike, Arkansas, on January 16, 1919, and carried home. It gives his serial number, his grade of Cook, and his birthplace: Natchez, Mississippi. The original is held by the family.
The companion Enlistment Record sheet for Thompson Hanes, handwritten, recording induction at Colfax, Louisiana, on September 18, 1917, foreign service from August 24, 1918, arrival overseas September 8, 1918, character Very Good, and his signature.
The enlistment record that goes with the discharge. It records his induction at Colfax on September 18, 1917, his crossing and return, a character of “Very Good,” and his own signature.
An oval portrait of Thompson Hanes in First World War uniform and campaign hat, in a dark wood frame under convex glass, hanging on a wall.
His First World War portrait as the family keeps it, in an oval frame under convex glass. The light spots are reflections in the glass.
A Louisiana voter registration certificate for 1953 to 1956, certificate number 51, Ward 10, Precinct 3, Parish of Rapides, made out to W. T. Hanes and signed by him.
His voter registration certificate for 1953–1956, issued at Rapides Parish on February 9, 1953, and signed W. T. Hanes. Bethie registered the same day, on the certificate numbered just before his.
A weathered marble headstone on a white marble base. The top is carved MOTHER. It reads Sefronia Hanes Milstead, June 26, 1868, Dec. 1, 1914, Our Mother is gone but not forgotten.
The headstone of his mother, Sophronia Hanes Milstead, which spells her name Sefronia. Photographed in January 2015; the cemetery has not yet been identified.

Notes on the record

Three records say March 2; three say different years

His 1919 discharge gives his age at induction on September 18, 1917, as twenty-five and a half, which points to a birth about March 1892. The 1900 census, the earliest record, gives March 1891 and his age as nine. His grave marker gives March 2, 1891, and his obituary gives his age at death in April 1984 as ninety-three, which agrees. His own draft registration of 1942 gives March 2, 1889, and the age he stated on it, fifty-three, agrees with that. The 1930 census gives his age as thirty-five, which would place his birth around 1894. Census ages were reported by whoever answered the enumerator’s questions and are often wrong. The Foundation does not choose between 1889 and 1891. It notes that the draft card is the only record he signed, and that the 1900 census is the one closest to his birth.

Natchez, and the records that say Louisiana

His 1919 discharge gives Natchez, in the State of Mississippi. His 1942 draft registration, which he signed, gives Natchez too, and the family confirms it. Three other sources give Louisiana: the 1900 census, the 1930 census, and his obituary of 1984, which calls him a native of Catahoula Parish. A census answer came from whoever spoke to the enumerator, and an obituary’s details pass through memory and then through a newspaper. Both often get birthplaces wrong. One detail explains where the obituary’s parish may come from. In 1914 his mother was buried at Jena, which the newspaper called “her old home,” and Jena lay in Catahoula Parish until LaSalle Parish was made from its western part in 1910. When Thompson was born, his mother’s home was in Catahoula Parish. Natchez lies about forty miles to the east, across the Mississippi. The Foundation follows his own statement and the family, and records the disagreement here. That is also why this site marks a birthplace taken from a census alone as partially confirmed rather than documented.

Hanes or Haynes

The 1900 census spells the family name Haynes, and a 1914 newspaper spells his name the same way. His own documents give Hanes. The Foundation uses Hanes and records the variant here, because a search for one spelling will miss the other.

Two sailing dates, and two descriptions

His enlistment record gives his departure from the United States as August 24, 1918. The Army transport list gives the sailing of the Persic from New York as August 26. A ship is loaded before it sails, and the two papers were written by different clerks for different purposes. The Foundation records both. The same is true of his description: the 1919 discharge gives blue eyes and five feet eight and a quarter inches, and the 1942 draft registration gives gray eyes and five feet six.

Thompson William, or William Thompson

The 1918 transport list names him Thompson Hanes. The 1930 census names him William T. The 1942 draft registration prints his name, with a misspelling, as Thompson William Hanes, and he signed it W. T. Hanes. His grave marker reads W. Thompson Hanes, and the family display sheet gives William Thompson Hanes, the form this site uses. He went by Thompson. The order of his given names is recorded here as found.

The date of the torpedoing

Some published accounts give September 12, 1918, for the attack on the Persic. The New York Times reported the attack on that date, which may explain the later date. The record of German submarine successes compiled at uboat.net gives September 7, 1918, which also fits a crossing that began in New York on August 26. The Foundation uses September 7.

“Thomas” in the newspaper caption

The clipping’s caption reads “Thomas Hanes, 93.” Every other source in the family record gives Thompson. A newspaper caption is a weak source against the rest of the record, and the Foundation records this as a probable misprint rather than an alternate name.

The date on the clipping: a correction

The clipping is annotated 1982 in pen, and its caption gives his age as ninety-three. An earlier version of this note measured that age against his grave marker, concluded that it pointed to 1984, and called the pen annotation likely wrong. His own draft registration gives a birth year of 1889. By that reckoning he turned ninety-three in March 1982, which agrees with the annotation. The earlier note is withdrawn. The clipping is now one more piece of evidence that 1889 may be the right year.

Open questions

  • Which birth year is right: 1889 or 1891.
  • His First World War draft registration of 1917, which may give a third birth date.
  • His father, recorded only as J. C. Hanes, born in Texas.
  • His veterans’ claim file. His obituary calls him a disabled veteran, and the Department of Veterans Affairs kept claim files apart from the service files lost in the 1973 fire.
  • A unit record or muster roll that names Company B aboard the Persic when she was torpedoed.
  • Where Company B served after it landed, and when he came home.
  • Whether his service file survived the 1973 fire.
  • The exact date of the newspaper clipping.
Portrait of Bethie Beatrice Farr Hanes as a young woman, wearing a dark hat with a floral ornament.

The mother

Bethie Beatrice Farr Hanes

1896 – 1973

The family display sheet is titled “Bethie and Thompson’s Four.” Her name comes first, and the Foundation has kept that order everywhere on this site.

There is no service record to request for Bethie. What she did does not generate paperwork. She raised four children in Louisiana between two world wars and then watched all four of them go, and there is no medal struck for that and no file in St. Louis that holds it.

The one Army document the Foundation holds from the First World War does name her. When Thompson’s company sailed from New York in August 1918, the passenger list recorded who was to be told if anything happened to him: Mrs. Bethie Hanes, his wife, at Whitehouse, Texas. Aubrey Lee was a year old.

The second mission of this Foundation is to tell the story of the Four and of their father and mother. She is half of that clause, and she is not a footnote to it.

One piece of paper in her own hand has now reached the Foundation. On February 9, 1953, she and Thompson walked into the registrar’s office in Rapides Parish and registered to vote. Their certificates are numbered 50 and 51. She wrote her name on hers: Mrs. Bethie Farr Hanes. It is a small thing and it is not a service record, and it is the only document here that she made herself.

She died six days before her seventy-seventh birthday, in December 1973.

The record as it stands

Born
December 28, 1896Documented

Grave marker

Birthplace
TexasPartial

1930 census, which also gives her father’s birthplace as Arkansas and her mother’s as Texas. A birthplace from a census alone is marked partial on this site.

Died
December 22, 1973Documented

Grave marker

Married
William Thompson HanesDocumented

Family display sheet. The 1918 Army transport list names her as his wife.

Home, 1918
Whitehouse, TexasDocumented

Named as Thompson’s wife and next of kin on the Army transport list, August 1918

Children who served
FourDocumented

Family display sheet

Maiden name
Farr, in her own handDocumented

Her 1953 voter registration certificate, which she signed “Mrs. Bethie Farr Hanes,” and the family. The family display sheet gives Furr; see the record note.

Registered to vote
February 9, 1953, Ward 10, Precinct 3, Rapides ParishDocumented

Louisiana voter registration certificate No. 50, for 1953–1956. Thompson’s certificate, No. 51, was issued the same day.

Bronze grave marker reading Bethie B. Hanes, December 28 1896 to December 22 1973, In Loving Memory.
Bethie B. Hanes, December 28, 1896 – December 22, 1973.
A Louisiana voter registration certificate for 1953 to 1956, certificate number 50, Ward 10, Precinct 3, Parish of Rapides, made out to Bethie Farr Hanes and signed Mrs. Bethie Farr Hanes.
Her voter registration certificate for 1953–1956, issued at Rapides Parish on February 9, 1953. She signed it “Mrs. Bethie Farr Hanes.” It is the first document the Foundation holds in her own hand.

Notes on the record

Farr, not Furr: a correction

Earlier versions of this site gave her maiden name as Furr, from the family display sheet. Her own signature, on her 1953 voter registration certificate, reads “Mrs. Bethie Farr Hanes,” and the registrar wrote Farr as well. The family holds that it was always Farr. A family dinner at Rigolette in 1941 was attended by the Rev. and Mrs. M. A. Farr, by Joyce Farr and by Carl Farr, all of Rigolette, who may be her people. This site now uses Farr. The display sheet’s spelling is recorded here, because it is what the sheet says.

Bethi, Bethie, Beth

The family display sheet gives “Bethi Beatrice Furr Hanes,” the only source for that spelling of either name. Her grave marker gives “Bethie B. Hanes,” and the sheet’s own title reads “Bethie and Thompson’s Four.” The two earliest documents the Foundation now holds, the Army’s 1918 transport list and the 1930 census, both give Bethie. The Foundation uses Bethie in running text and records the variance here rather than silently standardizing it.

Open questions

  • Her parents and the Farr family line. The 1930 census gives her father’s birthplace as Arkansas and her mother’s as Texas. The Farrs of Rigolette, who came to a family dinner in 1941, may be relatives.
  • Why she was at Whitehouse, Texas, in 1918, and whether it was her family’s home.
  • Photographs and correspondence from the war years.
  • Which spelling of her given name she used herself.
Newspaper clipping headed Rock of Aged. A photograph shows an elderly man in glasses playing a harmonica. The caption reads Thomas Hanes, 93, plays a harmonica ballad.

From the archive

A man is not only his war.

Near the end of his life Thompson was photographed by a local paper playing harmonica in a nursing home rhythm band, raising pledges for the heart association by the hour.

The Foundation keeps this clipping with the same care it keeps the uniforms. A collection that holds only the war years describes a soldier. It does not describe a man who came home, raised four children, and was still playing ballads at ninety-three.

Meet the Four →